Skip to content
prod 352bb92
Browse

6 · Consolidated verdict & launch handoff

Objective — synthesize the Phase 10 sub-reports into one GO / CONDITIONAL GO / NO-GO verdict, then prepare the Phase 11/12 handoff — the final audit gate where any unresolved high-risk item means do not advance.

Steps at a glance:

  1. Consolidated verdict — Synthesize the existing audit evidence. Do not run new tests here; missing evidence sends you back to the relevant Phase 10 step.
  2. Walk the pre-launch checklist — Confirm every area below before anyone makes a go/no-go call.
  3. Prepare the Phase 11/12 handoff — With a green checklist, record what Phase 11 must re-verify and what Phase 12 must execute later. Do not deploy production here.

The final gate. Phase 10 is not done until the static, deep, and functional audit evidence is consolidated into a single verdict. Everything before this phase fed into one decision — whether the app is ready for paying users.

Synthesize the existing audit evidence. Do not run new tests here; missing evidence sends you back to the relevant Phase 10 step.

Confirm these three sub-reports exist in Admin-Local/1-Project/4-Audit-Reports/ before producing the verdict:

  • YYYY-MM-DD-phase-10-A-security.md
  • YYYY-MM-DD-phase-10-B-perf-db-seo-a11y-cookies.md
  • YYYY-MM-DD-phase-10-C-testing-debugger.md
#DimensionEvidence sourceVerdict
1Code quality / static auditPhase 10 static auditGreen / advisory / blocker
2Composer CVEsPhase 10 static auditGreen / advisory / blocker
3Git hygiene + per-environment statePhase 10 static auditGreen / advisory / blocker
4Secrets and env exposurePhase 10 static auditGreen / advisory / blocker
5Production config / debug statePhase 10 security auditGreen / advisory / blocker
6Default admin credential rotationPhase 10 security auditGreen / advisory / blocker
7Demo content, vendor creds, and vendor-integrity scanPhase 10 security auditGreen / advisory / blocker
8Headers, TLS, and exposed filesPhase 10 security auditGreen / advisory / blocker
9Storage, admin, and upload exposurePhase 10 security auditGreen / advisory / blocker
10Runtime auth, rate limits, and IDOR checksPhase 10 functional QAGreen / advisory / blocker
11Core Web Vitals / LCPPhase 10 performance auditGreen / advisory / blocker
12Database indexes, slow queries, and N+1 checksPhase 10 DB auditGreen / advisory / blocker
13SEO indexing, canonical, robots, and sitemapPhase 10 SEO auditGreen / advisory / blocker
14AccessibilityPhase 10 accessibility auditGreen / advisory / blocker
15Cookies, consent, and privacy linksPhase 10 cookies auditGreen / advisory / blocker
16Functional golden pathsPhase 10 functional QAGreen / advisory / blocker
17Payment lifecyclePhase 10 functional QAGreen / advisory / blocker
18Transactional email deliveryPhase 10 functional QAGreen / advisory / blocker
19Debugger/log reviewPhase 10 functional QAGreen / advisory / blocker
20Monitoring data receivedAdmin-Local/1-Project/1-Info/monitoring-state.mdGreen / advisory / blocker
21Backup and rollback readinessPhase 7 + launch checklistGreen / advisory / blocker
22Open follow-ups classifiedZaj-BACKLOG.md audit deferralsGreen / advisory / blocker

Classify every unresolved item as one of:

  • Blocker — launch cannot proceed.
  • Advisory — launch can proceed only if the user explicitly accepts the risk.
  • Deferred to Zaj-BACKLOG.md — low severity or multi-hour vendor-template deferrals, such as lazy-load sweeps or bulk alt-text work.
VerdictMeaning
GOAll 22 rows are nonblank, zero blockers remain, advisories are explicitly accepted, and Phase 11 can start. Production deploy still waits for Phase 12.
CONDITIONAL GONo blockers remain, but one or more advisories need named owner/date follow-up before or immediately after launch.
NO-GOAny blocker remains, the vendor seed-surface sweep fails, reports are missing, or staging proof is incomplete.

Before stamping GO, confirm all of the following:

  • All 22 rows are filled in.
  • Rows 6 and 7 pass; any default admin, demo data, vendor credential, license beacon, or injected-script survivor is NO-GO.
  • Zero red/blocker rows remain.
  • Every advisory is accepted by the user with owner + review date.
  • At least one functional end-to-end golden path passed on the selected launch-candidate environment today.
  • Admin-Local/1-Project/1-Info/monitoring-state.md shows monitoring data is being received or a row is marked N/A with reason.
  • Zaj-PROGRESS.md logs the verdict, date, signer, and path to the consolidated report.
  • Zaj-BACKLOG.md rows from the deferred items carry source, severity, effort, trigger, and acceptance criterion — no disguised blockers (“defer” for a production breaker = NO-GO) and no vague/no-trigger rows.

Write the consolidated report to Admin-Local/1-Project/4-Audit-Reports/YYYY-MM-DD-phase-10-CONSOLIDATED.md. Phase 11’s first step transfers the 📋 Deferred to Zaj-BACKLOG.md rows into root Zaj-BACKLOG.md.

Confirm every area below before anyone makes a go/no-go call.

AreaVerify
BlockersNo unresolved HIGH / open ISSUE / SECURITY items in Zaj-BACKLOG.md or the Phase 10 audit reports
InfrastructureSSL > 30 days, DNS + www resolve, CDN proxy on, SSL mode Full (strict)
SecurityAPP_DEBUG=false, .env returns 403/404, no debug toolbar, Grade A headers (securityheaders.com) + SSL Labs (TLS) A/A+
MonitoringError tracking captures a test event, uptime monitor + backups verified
PaymentsStaging/test payment path passed, production keys/webhook are vaulted and scoped, and the Phase 11/12 human live-charge/refund gate is named
CommunicationsInbox-delivered welcome/reset/invoice emails, chat widget live
LegalPrivacy, Terms, Cookie, Refund pages published + linked; consent banner enforced
ContentNo placeholder text, favicon, OG/meta, sitemap, robots.txt correct
Team readinessAdmin creds in a vault with 2FA, rollback documented, 24h monitor assigned
  1. Verify every area, then make the go/no-go call. If any high-risk item is unresolved, do not launch.

    • ✅ All nine areas are green with zero unresolved HIGH / SECURITY items, and the sign-off is recorded.

With a green checklist, write the handoff that tells the next phases exactly what to re-verify and what not to run yet.

  1. Write the handoff inside the consolidated report and update trackers. The consolidated report must end with a short “Next-phase handoff” section.

    ## Next-phase handoff
    Verdict: GO | CONDITIONAL GO | NO-GO
    Phase 11 may start: yes/no
    Phase 12 production deploy may start now: no — wait for Phase 11 signoff and Phase 12 Task P.0
    Phase 11 re-verifies:
    - Technical readiness gates
    - Business/legal readiness
    - Support/onboarding readiness
    - Tiered go/no-go
    Phase 12 executes later:
    - production secret rotation/preflight
    - production backup/tag/release branch/deploy
    - live installer/auth checks
    - production seed-surface sweep
    - 24–48h production monitor
    Blockers:
    - none | list each blocker with owner and required proof
    Deferred polish transferred to Zaj-BACKLOG.md:
    - list each row source/severity/effort/trigger/acceptance
    Terminal window
    grep -n "Next-phase handoff" Admin-Local/1-Project/4-Audit-Reports/*phase-10-CONSOLIDATED.md
    grep -n "Phase 10-CONSOLIDATED" Zaj-PROGRESS.md
    grep -n "Deferred to Zaj-BACKLOG.md" Zaj-BACKLOG.md
    # Expected: consolidated report includes the handoff, Zaj-PROGRESS.md links the verdict,
    # and every deferred-polish row landed in Zaj-BACKLOG.md.
    • ✅ The consolidated report contains the next-phase handoff, Zaj-PROGRESS.md links the verdict, and every deferred polish row is in Zaj-BACKLOG.md.

Do not mark this step done until every box below is checked.

  • 🤖 Blockers clear — no unresolved HIGH / open ISSUE / SECURITY items in Zaj-BACKLOG.md or the Phase 10 audit reports.
  • 🔀 Consolidated verdict recorded — all 22 rows complete, verdict written to Admin-Local/1-Project/4-Audit-Reports/YYYY-MM-DD-phase-10-CONSOLIDATED.md, and Zaj-PROGRESS.md links it.
  • 🤖 Infrastructure ready — SSL > 30 days, DNS + www resolve, CDN proxy on, SSL mode Full (strict).
  • 🤖 Security verifiedAPP_DEBUG=false, .env returns 403/404, no debug toolbar; Grade A at securityheaders.com; SSL Labs (TLS) A or A+.
  • 🤖 Vendor seed-surface sweep — default admin credentials rotated, demo users/content removed, vendor-shipped encrypted creds/keys absent, and vendor-integrity scan clean; any survivor = NO-GO.
  • 🤖 Monitoring live — error tracking captures a test event, uptime monitor + backups verified.
  • 🔀 Payments ready — staging/test path passed; production keys/webhook are vaulted/scoped; live charge + refund are explicitly named as the later human gate.
  • 🤖 Communications working — inbox-delivered welcome/reset/invoice emails, chat widget live.
  • 🤖 Legal published — Privacy, Terms, Cookie, Refund pages published + linked; consent banner enforced.
  • 🤖 Content complete — no placeholder text, favicon, OG/meta, sitemap, robots.txt correct.
  • 🔀 Handoff ready — admin creds vaulted with 2FA, rollback documented, 24h monitor owner named, and the Phase 11/12 handoff is recorded.